Jamaican Journalism: Bleeding to mediocrity
25 Friday Sep 2009
Written by Corve DaCosta in Thoughts & Commentary
Tags
2009, blogging, camera, children, christianity, CNN, commentary, crime, crime and violence, criminal, Entertainment, Family, hate, Internet, Jamaica, journalism, Love & Relationships, man, News, newscast, parenting, Radio, reporters, technology, television, Thoughts & Commentary, TVJ, violence, woman
Share it
For many people who have visited or have heard of Jamaica, some of their thoughts are positive while others are negative. Jamaica is a wonderful paradise when you get to appreciate all the interesting scenes and places the island has to offer. However, just like many other countries around the world, we all have our issues. The USA has to deal with a recession; Cubans have to face living in a communist state. Well, Jamaicans face a plethora of issues that our previous leaders and present ones have all failed to correct. Not only do we face a recession like most countries but we encounter high levels of criminality daily, corruption in the public sector including politicians, average literacy rate, low productivity, high unemployment, the acceptance of illegal activities, a dying media that is in need of high journalistic standards and the list goes on.
As you may know Africans from the West Cost of Africa were shipped against their will to the Caribbean region. History reminds us that the most rebellious of the tribes came to Jamaica. This is one theory that is used to interpret our high crime levels over the years which continues today. Although politicians played a major role in the distribution of guns early on they have either failed to correct our crime situation or cannot right the issue of crime.
Jamaica is recognized as a third world country and it would appear that everything we do reminds us that we are in fact a developing country. Journalists in Jamaica are trained by a local media school at the University of the West Indies (UWI) called Caribbean Institute of Media and Communications (CARIMAC). In a recent column in the Jamaica Gleaner Carolyn Cooper who heads the department of Literary and Cultural Studies at UWI recently stated that the University of the West Indies is the only ‘real, real’ university here in Jamaica. For those who may not understand what she alluded to, she means the University of the West Indies is the only local institution that should be regarded at a ‘university’ bearing in mind we have many.
With a high crime rate like ours the newscasts are filled with stories reporting criminal activities. Moreover television newscasts go beyond the call of duty to record and report the bloody images not only in print but those aired on television. In recent times there have been attempts to have news agencies in Jamaica become more vigilant in how they report stories surrounding the topic of crime and violence since children, families and adults are all exposed.
For the past week in Jamaica there is an interesting discussion on whether a newscast on television went overboard in showing graphic images of a Rastafarian man chopping a cab driver for $20.00 (Jamaican) equivalent to $0.23 cents (American) and $0.24 cent (Canadian). The incident is not only shown once but is repeated more than three times in the news item. Although the presenter warned viewers of the graphic images in the story they should have shown more responsibility, compassion and journalistic character.
With the levels of crime and violence in Jamaica, some Jamaicans would appreciate if newscasts ignore some of the heinous incidents that happen daily. Personally, I do not know how comforting or ideal this would be but journalists would not agree with that position. Journalists should report on what is important to the society. This is not the first time this news agency has shown graphic images of incidents not fit for airplay. They are creating a bad name for themselves while degrading journalistic standards. I do agree that these incidents do happen (a clip slips through the cracks) but when it becomes a trend, viewers will stop taking you seriously. The media in Jamaica does not only suffer from low standards of journalism but we are out of control in airing outrageous lyrics on the airwaves. That is a whole other issue for another piece.
Jamaicans and Snitching
What is also startling in this story is how Jamaicans respond to violent incidents. In this video you can hear a woman shouting the man’s name “Bobby”. However, if you look carefully you will notice that people are not shocked or moved by what is taking place. No one rushes to call the police or 911, 811 or 119 here in Jamaica. They are going about their business as usual. Even moments after this incident takes place, eyewitnesses claimed they did not see anything. This is the reality Jamaicans live in. If they speak out about violent acts, they will be hunted down like hawks and killed for sharing information. It is not surprising that with a police station 15 feet away they were not aware of this incident till hours after. It is so sad living here.
Personal Note
I contemplated for long placing that horrific video on this blog. I thought about it and I am placing the video below. This video contains graphic images of a man chopping an innocent cab driver. After receiving multiple chop wounds the cab driver later drives his car to a nearby hospital where he was admitted in critical conditions. The driver is still alive today with the Rastafarian in police custody who was found with a bald head. This video grossed me out completely and has the ability to make you cringe in your seat. Just by looking at the screen shot below tells how graphic this gets.
[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Jtn_y0PW7g&hl=en&fs=1&color1=0x006699&color2=0x54abd6&border=1]
15 comments
September 26, 2009 at 12:24 AM
After awhile, one would become numb to the violence much like what we see on American TV so much so that when people on the street witness this violence, they often do nothing. When people rise up and refuse to accept this, it can stop.
Heinous crimes are still heinous and should be treated that way. Overexposure is wrong. What needs to happen in Jamaica to stop this?
[Reply]
September 26, 2009 at 9:31 AM
It is a shame that the media has the need to sensationalize everything, especially the gruesome. Just because they put a disclaimer out, they think they have done their duty. That does not cut it when children are watching.
By the way, the video has been taken down due to terms of use rules.
[Reply]
September 26, 2009 at 12:57 PM
WOW…
[Reply]
September 26, 2009 at 4:34 PM
I didn’t see the video because it is no longer available, but you know I am glad I didn’t because I know that scene would stay with me and just make me angry at the people walking around.
It must be very hard to live somewhere when things that are wrong and we should be shocked at seem commonplace.
Very important piece of writing.
Renee xoxo
[Reply]
September 26, 2009 at 5:47 PM
I’m so dismayed to read this, Corve. I found Jamaica to be an incredibly beautiful place, although I know that we just saw the “touristy” places, and that was not the reality on the entire island. I hope things will continue to progress and change for the better. There is so much potential there!
[Reply]
September 26, 2009 at 11:05 PM
WOW…….
[Reply]
September 27, 2009 at 7:44 AM
You are an amazing writer! I look forward to reading more…
[Reply]
September 27, 2009 at 12:40 PM
I have traveled to Jamaica and love her beauty and people. My heart breaks for the poverty and inequality. The tension there is just below the surface and given the Island’s past, it break out anytime between the Haves and Have Nots.
Great post, nice to meet.
[Reply]
September 28, 2009 at 5:36 AM
What a shame. No one stepped forward to reveal any information on the attacker?? -and there were atleast 20 people standing around. My heart goes out to the victim
[Reply]
Corve DaCosta Reply:
September 28th, 2009 at 7:03 AM
@NatalieXXX
Thanks for the comment. Days after the incident this Rastafarian was caught with a bald head. Clearly his religion went through the door-to change his identity.
[Reply]
September 28, 2009 at 10:17 PM
I saw this video earlier and I got to say they news station did the right thing. If they were to just speak about this than viewers could just dismiss it from their minds. But when you see the video you are shocked and you want something done with the quickness less you be the next victim this man attacks. Video’s like these can serve to motivate some one to do something. Aint no way in the world I am letting this animal around me after seeeing what he is capable of.
[Reply]
October 2, 2009 at 1:08 AM
Journalism in todays word has a hard choice to make when it comes to such material.
I agree 100% with you that some precaution needs to be taken and only certain videos (or photographs) should be shown to the public: those which do not portray gruesome or extremely violent scenes.
I grew up in Mexico and, to this day, the media in Mexico’s news papers and news channels will still portray graphic content such as the video you posted; Although extremely graphic, you have to, in a way, praise a country that still allows free expression and the ability to be able to publish material without censorship (although both Mexico and Jamaica will still prevent free speech and expression on certain subjects).
Now living in Canada, you will be surprised at how much the government controls the media, to the point that free speech and free expression is continuously dissappearing. There is so little journalistic liberty that writers with great ideas and views are forced to choose between their personal expression or their career, which in my opinion is very sad. In the USA, it is even worse.
On the other hand, I think it is wrong that journalists use this shocking material mainly to get money, rather than for the sake of journalism. What we need to find is a happy medium, where journalists stick to the facts, using great written artistry to make a point, and use visual aids only to add to their writing, without going over board with overly graphic material.
-As for violence altogether, it is sad what many Jamaican’s have to go through. Jamaica is such a beautiful country with a fantastic and unique culture; it is unfortunate that people (especially those who work hard to earn a high standard of living) need to either live in a world where they always have to watch their back, or leave their home country in search of a safer life.
[Reply]
October 4, 2009 at 4:41 PM
Mi nah guh lie…Corve…Dis one really mek mi jus shake my head in shame.
Corve, Jamaica really turn into a war zone…more so than I remember when I was living there. I remember when we used have curfew back in the late 80s because of JLP/PNP violence. After a while, you would think that enough people would be just sick and tired of this. Although crime is out of control, opportunities/economic growth are scarce, and the society is just eroding away…I am hard pressed to really lost the last shred of optimism I have in the ability for things to change. I have no idea what it will take, but until a self-less attitude is fostered in JA, nothing will change. When I say self-less, I don’t even mean a spirit of charity, but what I mean is a spirit of not feeling sorry for yourself anymore and a push back against negativity.
Jamaica…we are better than this.
[Reply]
Corve DaCosta Reply:
October 4th, 2009 at 4:58 PM
@Aurie
Thanks for the comment.
Jamaica is one big ghetto. The politicians do not have the guts to make the changes that this place. It would appear that they like the island as it is as they rely on people in these conditions to put them in power over and over again. We are much better than this. I guess the good ones will migrate never to return. Hmmmm
[Reply]
October 5, 2009 at 3:52 PM
interesting
[Reply]